As we advance into 2025, the best ecommerce platform landscape is more dynamic and competitive than ever. Amazon, Walmart, and Shopify have emerged as dominant forces, each carving out unique niches and strategies to capture market share. This comprehensive analysis delves into their current standings, growth trajectories, technological innovations, and the challenges they face, aiming to provide insights into which platform might lead the e-commerce sector by the end of 2025. The best ecommerce platform?
The best eCommerce platform landscape in 2025
The global e-commerce market is projected to reach $6.56 trillion in 2025, with online sales accounting for an increasing share of total retail sales. This growth is fueled by factors such as increased internet penetration, mobile device usage, and changing consumer behaviors. The best ecommerce platform?
Amazon: The E-Commerce Titan
Strengths
- Market Dominance: Amazon is projected to account for 40.5% of U.S. retail e-commerce sales in 2025, translating to approximately $491.65 billion.
- Technological Advancements: Amazon continues to invest heavily in artificial intelligence and machine learning to enhance customer experience and streamline operations.
- Prime Ecosystem: With over 200 million Prime members globally, Amazon leverages this subscription model to foster customer loyalty and increase purchase frequency.
Challenges
- Regulatory Scrutiny: Amazon faces increased regulatory pressure, particularly in Europe. Germany’s Federal Cartel Office has raised concerns about Amazon’s pricing mechanisms potentially breaching competition laws by restricting third-party sellers’ pricing freedom.
- Third-Party Seller Relations: There is ongoing criticism regarding Amazon’s treatment of third-party sellers, including concerns over data usage and competitive practices.
Amazon Seller Central
Features for Sellers
- Selling Plans: Choose between Individual (pay-per-sale) and Professional (monthly subscription) plans.
- Fulfillment Options: Fulfillment by Amazon (FBA) for storage and shipping, or Fulfillment by Merchant (FBM) for self-fulfillment.
- Product Listings: Access to a vast customer base with tools for listing products, managing inventory, and setting prices.
- Advertising Tools: Sponsored Products, Brands, and Display ads to increase visibility.
- Analytics: Detailed reports on sales, traffic, and customer behavior.
Potential Drawbacks
- Fees: Referral fees, closing fees, and FBA fees can accumulate.
- Competition: High competition, including from Amazon’s own private labels.
- Account Management: Strict policies may lead to account suspensions for policy violations.
How to Create an Amazon Seller Account
- Visit: Amazon Seller Central
- Sign Up: Click “Sign Up” and choose your selling plan.
- Provide Information:
- Business name and address
- Phone number
- Tax information
- Bank account and credit card details
- Verification: Submit identification documents and complete phone verification.
- Set Up Store: Customize your seller profile and start listing products.
Amazon Reviews
How Reviews Work
- Customer-Generated: Buyers can leave star ratings (1–5) and detailed text reviews after purchase.
- Verified Purchase Tag: Reviews are marked as “Verified Purchase” if Amazon can confirm the buyer bought the product through the platform.
- Aggregated: Star rating averages are displayed prominently on the product page.
Pros
- High Trust Value: Amazon reviews carry significant influence because of the platform’s credibility.
- Quantity Boosts Sales: Products with 4★ or above and a high volume of reviews tend to perform better in search rankings and conversions.
- Amazon Vine: For Professional Sellers, Amazon offers the Vine Program—invite-only customers (Vine Voices) receive free products in exchange for honest reviews.
Cons
- Strict Review Policies: Incentivizing reviews (e.g., offering free products or money) is prohibited outside the Vine program.
- Removal Difficulty: Getting unfair or fraudulent reviews removed is difficult and handled case-by-case.
- Review Bombing: Popular products may be targeted by competitors with negative reviews.
Tips to Get Reviews
- Use Amazon’s “Request a Review” button in Seller Central (1x per order).
- Participate in Vine (if eligible).
- Provide excellent packaging and service to naturally prompt organic reviews.
Amazon Seller Experience in 2024
Seller Preferences
- Market Dominance: Amazon remains a top choice for many sellers due to its vast customer base and robust fulfillment network.
- Fulfillment Options: Sellers appreciate the choice between Fulfillment by Amazon (FBA) and Fulfillment by Merchant (FBM), allowing flexibility based on business needs.
- Advertising Tools: Amazon’s advertising platform offers various options to boost product visibility.
Seller Concerns
- Fee Increases: Sellers have expressed frustration over new fees introduced in 2024, including inbound placement, low inventory, and high return rate fees. These additions have tightened profit margins and led to criticism of Amazon’s seller support.
- Buy Box Challenges: The Buy Box algorithm, which favors the lowest-priced listings, has been a point of contention. Sellers facing increased costs due to tariffs find it challenging to compete without sacrificing profitability.
- Review Authenticity: Concerns have arisen over the authenticity of product reviews, with reports of fake or misleading reviews affecting consumer trust.
Walmart: The Retail Behemoth’s Digital Transformation
Strengths
- Omnichannel Presence: With over 10,500 stores worldwide, Walmart leverages its physical footprint to enhance its e-commerce capabilities, offering services like curbside pickup and same-day delivery.
- E-Commerce Growth: Walmart’s online sales have surpassed $100 billion, marking a significant milestone in its digital transformation journey.
- Technological Investments: Walmart is investing in AI and automation to improve supply chain efficiency and customer experience. For instance, its partnership with Symbotic aims to automate warehouse operations across 400 distribution centers.
Challenges
- Profitability Pressures: Despite robust online sales growth, Walmart’s overall revenue growth has slowed, with forecasts predicting a 3-4% increase in net sales for FY26, down from 5.1% in 2024.
- Workforce Management: Walmart has increased revenue by over $150 billion over five years while reducing its global headcount by nearly 70,000, highlighting a shift toward automation. This approach has drawn criticism for prioritizing productivity over wage growth.
Walmart Marketplace
Features for Sellers
- No Monthly Fees: Pay only referral fees on sales.
- Seller Center: Dashboard to manage listings, orders, and performance metrics.
- Shipping Options: Flexible shipping settings, including Walmart Fulfillment Services (WFS).
- Promotions: Tools to create discounts and special offers.
- Customer Base: Access to Walmart’s extensive online audience.
Potential Drawbacks
- Approval Process: Application review can take time and is selective.
- Integration: Limited third-party integrations compared to other platforms.
- Brand Recognition: Less emphasis on individual seller branding.
How to Create a Walmart Seller Account
- Apply: Visit Walmart Marketplace and click “Join Marketplace”.
- Provide Information:
- US Business Tax ID and EIN
- Business address and contact information
- Product categories and catalog size
- Verification: Submit required documents for business verification.
- Set Up Seller Center: Configure shipping, returns, and payment settings.
- List Products: Upload product listings and go live upon approval.
Walmart Reviews
How Reviews Work
- Walmart Reviews Are Centralized: Reviews often apply across all sellers offering the same UPC/SKU.
- Post-Purchase Emails: Walmart sends automatic review request emails to customers.
- Review Syndication: Reviews from brands’ D2C websites (via Bazaarvoice) can be syndicated to Walmart product listings.
Pros
- Automatic Requests: Walmart automates the review request process—no manual outreach needed.
- Less Saturated: Lower review volume than Amazon means early reviews can have a stronger impact.
- Walmart Spark Reviewer Program: Invited reviewers receive free products and leave detailed reviews.
Cons
- Shared Reviews: If multiple sellers offer the same item, reviews are not specific to one seller’s experience or shipping performance.
- Difficult to Influence: Limited tools or approved programs for boosting reviews.
- Removal Policies: Negative reviews that violate Walmart’s guidelines can be flagged but are not always removed quickly.
Tips to Get Reviews
- Ensure fast shipping and accurate listings to minimize negative experiences.
- Enroll in the Spark Reviewer program if available.
- Partner with agencies that offer review syndication via Bazaarvoice.
Walmart Marketplace Seller Experience in 2024
Seller Preferences
- Platform Enhancements: Walmart has introduced several improvements to its Seller Center, including enhanced item search capabilities, improved sales reporting, and better duplicate item management. These updates aim to streamline seller operations.
- Review Accelerator Program: This initiative allows sellers to incentivize customers for reviews, helping new products gain credibility faster.
- SEM Suggestions: Walmart’s Success Hub now offers tailored Search Engine Marketing suggestions, aiding sellers in optimizing their external marketing efforts.
Seller Concerns
- Platform Glitches: Sellers have reported issues with inventory management, where products show as out of stock despite available inventory, leading to lost sales.
- Customer Support: Feedback indicates that seller support is often unresponsive or lacks the necessary knowledge to resolve issues effectively.
- Automatic Refunds: Instances of Walmart issuing customer refunds without notifying sellers have been reported, causing financial discrepancies and trust issues.
Shopify: Empowering Entrepreneurs
Strengths
- Merchant Empowerment: Shopify provides a user-friendly platform for small and medium-sized businesses to establish and manage online stores, fostering entrepreneurship.
- Global Reach: With over 1.7 million businesses using Shopify as of 2023, the platform has a significant global presence, enabling merchants to reach a wide audience.
- Technological Enhancements: Shopify is investing in AI-driven tools to assist merchants in optimizing their sales strategies. Its AI assistant, Sidekick, has seen a doubling in monthly average user count since the beginning of the year.
Challenges
- Scalability Concerns: As businesses grow, they may encounter limitations with Shopify’s scalability, particularly regarding reliance on third-party apps for additional functionality.
- Competitive Pressure: Shopify faces stiff competition from larger platforms like Amazon and Walmart, which can offer lower prices and faster shipping options.
Shopify
Features for Sellers
- Customizable Storefront: Design your own branded online store with various themes.
- App Integrations: Access to over 8,000 apps for marketing, sales, and operations.
- Payment Processing: Built-in Shopify Payments and support for multiple gateways.
- Sales Channels: Sell across various platforms, including social media and marketplaces.
- Analytics: Comprehensive reports on sales, customer behavior, and marketing.
Potential Drawbacks
- Monthly Fees: Subscription costs vary based on the plan and add-ons.
- Self-Marketing: Responsibility for driving traffic to your store.
- Learning Curve: May require time to learn and optimize store settings and apps.
How to Create a Shopify Store
- Start Free Trial: Go to Shopify and click “Start free trial”.
- Create Account: Enter your email, password, and store name.
- Set Up Store:
- Choose a theme and customize your storefront
- Add products with descriptions and images
- Configure payment and shipping settings
- Launch Store: Select a subscription plan and publish your store.
Shopify Reviews
How Reviews Work
- Store-Specific: Reviews are left directly on the merchant’s site—each store manages its own system.
- App-Based System: Requires apps like:
- Shopify Product Reviews (free)
- Loox
- Yotpo
- Judge.me
Pros
- Full Control: Merchants can approve, moderate, or even reply to reviews (depending on the app).
- Photo/Video Reviews: Some apps support media uploads for social proof.
- Email Automation: Many apps can send automated review request emails post-purchase.
Cons
- Trust Factor: Customers may trust Shopify reviews less than those on Amazon due to possible moderation bias.
- Requires Apps: Native Shopify lacks a robust review system—apps are necessary (some are paid).
- Scalability: Review collection is slower unless you invest in marketing, email flows, or incentives.
Tips to Get Reviews
- Set up an automated email flow via Loox or Judge.me for 3–7 days post-delivery.
- Offer small loyalty points or discounts for review submissions (compliant with guidelines).
- Display star ratings on product pages, homepage, and Google Shopping via schema markup.
Shopify Seller Experience in 2024
Seller Preferences
- Customization: Shopify offers extensive customization options, allowing sellers to create unique storefronts that align with their brand identity.
- App Ecosystem: A vast array of apps, such as Stamped Product Reviews & UGC, enable sellers to enhance functionality, from collecting customer reviews to integrating with Google Shopping for improved SEO.
- Ownership and Control: Sellers value the autonomy Shopify provides, granting full control over their online store operations.
Seller Concerns
- Traffic Generation: Unlike marketplaces like Amazon or Walmart, Shopify doesn’t have a built-in customer base, requiring sellers to invest in marketing to drive traffic to their stores.
- App Costs: While many apps enhance store functionality, the cumulative cost of multiple paid apps can add up, impacting profitability.
- Learning Curve: New sellers may face a learning curve in setting up and optimizing their Shopify store, especially without prior e-commerce experience.
Projected Growth and Trends
- Mobile Commerce: Mobile commerce is projected to account for $2.51 trillion of global e-commerce sales in 2025, emphasizing the importance of mobile-optimized platforms.
- Sustainability: Consumers are increasingly prioritizing sustainability, influencing purchasing decisions. Companies that emphasize ethical practices and sustainable sourcing are likely to gain a competitive edge.
- Artificial Intelligence: AI is playing a crucial role in personalizing shopping experiences, optimizing supply chains, and enhancing customer service across e-commerce platforms.
Conclusion: Who Leads in 2025?
Determining a definitive winner among Amazon, Walmart, and Shopify in 2025 depends on various factors, including market focus, technological innovation, and adaptability.
- Amazon: Maintains a stronghold in the e-commerce sector with its vast product selection, advanced logistics, and technological prowess. However, regulatory challenges and seller relations require careful navigation.
- Walmart: Demonstrates significant progress in digital transformation, leveraging its physical stores to enhance online offerings. Continued investment in technology and customer experience positions it as a formidable competitor.
- Shopify: Continues to empower entrepreneurs and small businesses, fostering innovation and diversity in the e-commerce space. Addressing scalability and competitive pressures will be key to its sustained growth.
The best ecommerce platform
Each platform offers distinct advantages:
- Amazon: Ideal for reaching a vast customer base with established fulfillment services.
- Walmart: Offers access to a large audience with competitive referral fees.
- Shopify: Provides full control over branding and customer experience.
Choose the best ecommerce platform that aligns with your business goals, resources, and target audience.
Final Verdict on Reviews
| Platform | Review Trust | Control | Tools for Sellers | Difficulty to Get Reviews | Review Impact |
| Amazon | ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ | Low | Vine, Request Button | Moderate to Hard | Very High |
| Walmart | ⭐⭐⭐⭐ | Medium-Low | Spark, Post-Purchase Emails | Moderate | High |
| Shopify | ⭐⭐⭐ | High | Loox, Yotpo, Judge.me | Easy to Moderate | Medium |
Comparative Overview
| Aspect | Amazon | Walmart | Shopify |
| Ease of Entry | Moderate (due to competition and fees) | Moderate (application process required) | High (user-friendly setup) |
| Seller Support | Mixed reviews | Generally negative feedback | Generally positive feedback |
| Customization | Limited | Limited | Extensive |
| Traffic Source | Built-in customer base | Built-in customer base | Requires external marketing |
| Review System | Strict policies, issues with authenticity | Incentivized reviews via Accelerator | Full control with various app integrations |
| Fees | Multiple fees impacting margins | Lower fees but potential hidden costs | Subscription and app fees |
In summary, each platform offers distinct advantages and challenges:
- Amazon: Provides access to a vast customer base but comes with increased fees and competition.
- Walmart: Offers growth opportunities with recent platform enhancements but still faces operational and support challenges.
- Shopify: Grants full control and customization but requires proactive efforts in marketing and potential additional costs for apps.
Sellers should assess their business needs, resources, and goals to choose the platform that aligns best with their strategy.
Ultimately, the “winner” of the best ecommerce platform in 2025 will be determined by each platform’s ability to adapt to evolving consumer preferences, technological advancements, and regulatory landscapes.
Let us help you align your store name with a solid, conversion-based brand strategy; may it be Amazon, Walmart or eBay. Book your success now: https://calendly.com/swifsol/30min
📩Reach out today: info@swifsol.com
🌐Visit us: www.swifsol.com
📅Book a consultation: https://calendly.com/swifsol/30minhttps://calendly.com/swifsol/30min